Sell to us
We buy collections, bulk, and individual chase cards — Magic, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh! and One Piece. Cash or store credit, and store credit always pays more.
What we are looking for
- Modern and Commander staples in any condition down to HP.
- Sealed product, current and out of print.
- Bulk — commons and uncommons by the thousand, and rare lots.
- Whole collections, including the shoebox that has been in the closet since 2004.
- Graded slabs — PSA, BGS, CGC.
How it works
| Step | What happens |
|---|---|
| 1. Tell us | Send a list, a spreadsheet, or just photos of what you have. For bulk, a rough count is fine. |
| 2. We quote | You get a per-card or per-lot offer, cash and store credit side by side, with the condition we graded each card at. |
| 3. You decide | Take it, counter it, or walk away. No pressure and no fee either way. |
| 4. Ship or drop off | If you accept, sort the cards to match the offer and send them over. |
| 5. We pay | Paid once the cards land and match the grades quoted. Store credit is instant. |
A word on grading your own cards
Grade them honestly and the process is quick. If a card comes in a grade below what was quoted, we re-quote that line rather than voiding the whole offer — but a batch that is uniformly optimistic slows everything down for both of us.
Not sure how to grade? Our grading guide is the same one we use on the bench.
Buylist quotes are good for 7 days. Market prices on staples move fast, and we would rather re-quote than pretend otherwise.